5 insurance mistakes restaurant depot owners make
Five mistakes cost restaurant depot owners the most: insuring stock at its average value instead of its peak, leaving forklifts off every policy, running sprinklers that do not match how high the stock is stacked, sending out deliveries with drivers who are on no business auto policy, and keeping cash on hand without coverage for it. Each can show up as a short payout, a denied claim or an uninsured bill, and each is cheaper to fix before a loss. This page covers the commercial policies a depot buys, not personal insurance.
Photo by Maxim Tolchinskiy
on Unsplash
- A property limit set from average stock can fall short in the busiest weeks, when the most stock is on the floor.
- Forklifts and delivery vehicles are often the pieces left off a policy built for a store. Ask to see where each one is written.
- On many policies, fire coverage depends on sprinklers that work and suit what is stored. Cash needs its own coverage.
Mistake 1: What happens if I insure only my average stock?
If the limit on your property policy is set from average stock, a loss in your busiest weeks can exceed it, and you would carry the difference. The stock and equipment inside your building are what insurers call business personal propertyBusiness Personal Property (BPP) The things inside your business you would have to replace after a loss, such as furniture, equipment, inventory, and supplies. Insurers call this business personal property. more →, and the number to report is the value at its peak.
Fires in warehouse-use buildings averaged 1,544 a year from 2020 to 2024, with $314 million in direct property damage a year. That count leaves out warehouses attached to retail and refrigerated storage, so it stands in for the storage exposure; it is not a depot count. (Source: National Fire Protection Association)
Picture a depot that insures the stock it holds in a typical month, then stocks up for the holidays. If a loss hits in that stretch, the policy may pay only up to the lower limit. Some policies also cut every payout in proportion when the insured amount is below the share of value the policy requires; insurers call that coinsurance. Whether yours does is in the policy wording.
The fix. Pull the monthly stock counts for the last year and give your agent the highest, not the average. Ask whether a policy that follows your stock as you report it fits better than a flat limit, and whether stock is valued at cost or at selling price. Read what business personal property is and how property coverage works.
Mistake 2: Who insures my forklifts?
The forklifts you own are often missing from a policy written for the building and its contents. They are usually insured as equipment that moves around, which insurers call inland marineInland Marine Coverage for business property that moves or sits away from your premises, such as tools, equipment, or goods in transit. Insurers call it inland marine. more →, and a leased forklift can bring insurance terms of its own in the lease.
Federal rules require every forklift operator to be trained and evaluated, with a fresh evaluation at least once every three years. (Source: Occupational Safety and Health Administration) The Bureau of Labor Statistics counted 74 forklift-related worker deaths in 2017, the latest year in its forklift fact sheet; the agency has since changed how it classifies events, so later years do not compare. (Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics)
Two different policies are in play. Injury to your own staff goes to workers' comp. Injury to a customer or vendor on the floor is a claim on your liability policy, and an insurer often asks first whether forklift lanes are kept apart from customer aisles. If a forklift is stolen, damaged or involved in a loss and it sits on no policy, the cost could be yours.
The fix. List every forklift, pallet jack and powered cart with its owner, value and who runs it, and ask your agent where each one is written. Keep the training records. See inland marine coverage and liability coverage.
Mistake 3: Do my sprinklers match how high I stack?
They may not, and an insurer can treat the mismatch as a reason to decline the building or to attach a condition. Sprinklers are designed for a stated storage height and kind of stock, so adding racking or a higher stack can leave a working system that no longer fits what is under it.
The model fire code's high-piled storage rules start once the top of storage passes 12 feet, or 6 feet for high-hazard goods. Where the area is open to the public and stock is moved by machine, it calls for aisles at least 96 inches wide, against 44 inches in other sprinklered high-piled areas. (Source: 2021 International Fire Code, chapter 32, as adopted by a local jurisdiction) Many places use a different edition or a different model code, so your local fire marshal confirms the trigger.
Timing matters. Between midnight and 6 a.m., fires made up 18% of warehouse-use fires but 40% of the property damage, the same report that carries the figures above. (Source: National Fire Protection Association) It leaves out retail-attached and refrigerated storage, so treat it as a stand-in. A policy can also require the safeguards to stay in service. That clause is called a protective safeguard endorsementProtective Safeguard Endorsement A policy add-on requiring you to keep named safety systems, such as sprinklers or a monitored alarm, working, or the insurer may deny a related claim. Insurers call it a protective safeguard endorsement. more →, and if its conditions are not met the insurer can deny a related claim.
The fix. Before you add racking or raise stacks, get the sprinkler design checked against the new height and stock, and keep the inspection records. Tell your agent in writing when the layout changes. See why a restaurant depot is hard to insure for how underwriters read storage.
Mistake 4: What if my delivery drivers are on no policy?
A crash on a delivery run can become your bill if the truck or the driver is on no business auto policy. A liability policy written for a store is not designed to follow a vehicle onto the road.
Staff who deliver in their own cars are a second gap. Their personal auto policy may not be enough for a serious crash, and the injured people could look to the business. The Insurance Information Institute notes that a personal umbrella typically excludes claims from business use of a vehicle, and that many insurers recommend a business auto limit of $1,000,000 with $500,000 as the minimum. (Source: Insurance Information Institute) Cover for cars the business does not own is called hired and non-owned autoHired and Non-Owned Auto Liability coverage for accidents in vehicles your business does not own, such as rentals or an employee's personal car used on a work errand. Insurers call it hired and non-owned auto. more →.
The fix. Put every truck on a commercial auto policy and give your agent a current driver list. When a delivery driver joins, check the policy before the first route; what changes when you hire a driver walks through it. If staff use their own cars for errands, ask for hired and non-owned cover by name.
Mistake 5: Is the cash in my registers and safe covered?
Usually not by the standard property and liability package. Money and goods stolen by an employee, a robber or a forger are what insurers call crime coverageCrime Coverage Coverage for money and goods stolen by an employee, a robber or a forger, which the standard property and liability package does not include. Insurers call it crime coverage. more →, and a depot that sells for cash and keeps it on site may need it.
No public source counts cash theft at cash-and-carry stores, so this section explains the exposure and gives no loss figure. What is clear is how the policies divide the work: the property policy is built around the building and stock, and it often limits what it pays for money. Ask your agent for the limit written for money and for theft by employees, and whether it differs for cash in the safe and cash in a bank bag.
The fix. Write down the most cash you hold on a typical day and on the busiest, and where it sits overnight. Give your agent both numbers and ask where each is covered. Review the answer whenever you add a register or a location. See five coverage gaps in a typical depot policy for the others. How to compare insurance quotes shows how to check one quote against another line by line.
Common questions about restaurant depot insurance mistakes
Often, yes. Tell your agent in writing as soon as you notice it, so the insurer can correct the policy or reprice it. A correction before a loss is far safer than a discovery after one.
At every renewal, and before any season when you stock up. Also review it whenever you add racking, a freezer room or a location.
Yes. The mix of sales to businesses and to the public can change how the insurer sees the premises and how workers' comp is classed. Tell your agent before the change, not at renewal.
Find out which of these gaps your policy may be hiding
Send us your current policy, your peak stock figure and your equipment and driver lists, and we will compare them with how your depot actually runs.