I rent out space in my commercial building — what insurance should I require from tenants?
Ask each tenant for liability insurance that names you, cover on its own property, and proof you can check. Your lease and your lender set the amounts. Collect copies of the written add-ons, not just a certificate, and ask your attorney which waivers belong in the lease.
Photo by Sebastian Herrmann
on Unsplash
- Your lease and your lender set the dollar limits, so this guide gives none.
- A certificate is information only and gives you no rights. The written add-ons that name you are what count.
- Who insures a tenant's improvements, and what happens to rent after a loss, belong in the lease.
What should I require from the tenants in my building?
Require liability insurance that names you, cover on the tenant's own property, and proof you can check. Your lease and your lender set the amounts. The table shows what each requirement does and what to collect.
| What you require of the tenant | What it does for you | What to collect |
|---|---|---|
| A liability policy that names you | Gives you rights under the tenant's policy for claims tied to its space | A copy of the written add-on, not only the certificate |
| Each side's insurer gives up the right to sue the other | Stops an insurer that paid a fire claim from suing you or the tenant | The lease clause and each policy's add-on; ask your attorney |
| A liability limit | Sets how much the tenant's policy can pay for a claim | A certificate showing the limits your lease and your lender set |
| Who insures the tenant's improvements | Prevents a gap, or two policies paying for the same thing | A lease line on who insures them, adjusts the loss and is paid |
| Cover on the tenant's own property | Leaves the tenant's stock and equipment to the tenant's policy | A certificate showing property cover |
| What happens to rent when the space can't be used | Rent usually stops while your mortgage, taxes and upkeep go on | The lease's rent clause and your own loss-of-rents limit |
| Notice if the tenant's policy is cancelled | Warns you before the cover ends | A lease clause, and an endorsement if the insurer agrees |
| Proof of every policy | Shows what the tenant bought; a certificate gives you no rights | The certificate plus copies of the add-ons, renewed each year |
| What your lender asks of your own policy | Your policy, not the tenant's, carries your lender's requirements | The insurance section of your loan documents |
| A restaurant tenant's fire records | Shows the hood and ducts are cleaned and the fire systems work | Inspection record, service tag, suppression service date |
A certificate is information only and gives you no rights. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) To see how a tenant reads these clauses, read what to do when a landlord requires insurance.
How do my policy and my tenants' policies fit together?
Commercial leases commonly have the owner insure the building and each tenant insure its own belongings. Each side also carries its own liability policy. Your lease sets the details.
Most commercial leases pass the building's insurance cost to tenants as rent. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) You still hold the building policy. Your lender usually asks for it, and your policy, not a tenant's, carries your lender's requirements. If one tenant insures the whole building, you and your lender should be named on that policy. Ask your attorney.
Leasehold improvementsLeasehold Improvements Walls, flooring, fixtures and other build-out inside a rented space. The lease decides whether the owner or the tenant insures them. Insurers call them leasehold improvements. more → are the walls, flooring and fixtures a tenant builds inside its space. A silent lease can leave a gap, or two policies paying for the same thing. A lease-law paper says that with several tenants it is usually best for the owner who insures the shell to insure the improvements too. One insurer on both makes rebuilding easier and can cost less. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) If you do, ask your agent whether your building limit should rise to match. (Source: Stoel Rives, landlord insurance article, 2024) Ask your attorney how your leases divide them.
Rent is the other piece. A tenant's rent usually stops while its space cannot be used. Your mortgage, taxes and upkeep do not. Loss of rents pays the rent a covered loss stops you collecting. Landlords sometimes also ask a tenant for its own business interruption cover, depending on the tenant's finances. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) Our guide to what insurance a commercial building owner needs explains your own policies.
What happens if a claim starts in a tenant's space?
Your own policy is the first place to look, and the tenant's policy may help if you are named on it. Two written add-ons decide how much help. One names you. The other stops insurers suing each other.
An additional insuredAdditional Insured Another person or business covered under your liability policy for claims tied to your work or property, such as a landlord or general contractor. Insurers call them an additional insured. more → is a party added to someone else's liability policy, so it has direct rights under that policy. Read its wording. A lease clause saying the tenant's policy pays first does not bind its insurer unless the add-on says so. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017)
A waiver of subrogationWaiver of Subrogation A policy add-on where your insurer gives up the right to pursue a party you agreed by contract not to blame after a loss. Insurers call it a waiver of subrogation. more → means an insurer gives up the right to recover from a party the insured agreed not to blame. Lease guidance says a lease should include a mutual one. It typically does not change the premium. Policies vary, so ask each insurer whether it allows one. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) Ask your attorney whether a waiver suits your building.
You can also ask for cover that fits what a tenant does. A landlord can ask for cover that fits what the tenant does, such as liquor liability for a tenant that serves alcohol. (Source: Stoel Rives, landlord insurance article, 2024) Your own general liability policy is designed to respond to claims from your common areas and parking lot. To see what it pays for, read our general liability page.
Is a certificate enough proof of a tenant's insurance?
No. A certificate of insuranceCertificate of Insurance (COI) A one-page proof of your coverage, showing the insurer, policy number, and limits, that you hand to a landlord or client. Insurers call it a certificate of insurance. more → is a one-page summary of a tenant's coverage. It gives you no rights, so collect the add-ons too.
Certificates no longer promise that the insurer will warn you before it cancels. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) Put the notice requirement in the lease, and ask whether the insurer will add it. Our guide to what a certificate is explains the form.
Picture an owner who files a new tenant's certificate. A year later the tenant changes insurers, and the first policy ends with its add-ons. Nobody asks for new ones. If a customer is hurt in the tenant's unit and sues the owner, no current policy may name her.
Ask for a new certificate and fresh add-ons at each renewal. Our guide to insurance mistakes commercial building owners make explains how it gets missed.
What should I ask of a restaurant tenant?
Ask for its hood and duct cleaning record, its fire-suppression service date and proof the sprinklers stay on.
Cooking starts 30% of non-residential building fires. (Source: US Fire Administration, Nonresidential Building Fires, 2021) So tell your agent when a restaurant moves in. A hood suppression systemHood Suppression System A fire-extinguishing system built into a commercial kitchen hood and duct that sprays chemical over the cooking line when a fire starts. Insurers call it a hood suppression system. more → sprays chemical over the cooking line when a fire starts, so ask when it was last serviced.
Your fire code official sets how often hoods and ducts are inspected. New York's fire code is one example. It also asks for written records and a service tag. (Source: Fire Code, section 607 on kitchen hoods, 2020)
| Kind of cooking | Hoods and ducts inspected every |
|---|---|
| High-volume: 24-hour, charbroiling or wok cooking | 3 months |
| All other cooking | 6 months |
| Low-volume: places of worship, seasonal businesses, senior centers | 12 months |
| Solid fuel | 1 month |
Put the records in the lease, and have the tenant tell you before any sprinkler shut-off. Our guide to why some buildings are hard to insure explains what insurers weigh.
Common questions about tenant insurance for building owners
Usually yes. Commercial leases commonly have the owner insure the building and common areas. Each tenant insures its own belongings. Your lender also commonly asks for building cover. Ask your attorney how your leases divide it.
Your lease decides what you can do, so ask your attorney. Ask for the certificate and the add-ons in writing before the tenant moves in. Then your request is on file.
Ask for a new certificate and new copies of the add-ons. The add-ons end when the policy ends, so a file that holds only old ones shows nothing current.
Check your leases against your own policy
Bring the insurance sections of your leases and we will go through them with you.