5 insurance mistakes commercial building owners make
Five mistakes can leave a commercial building owner's insurance short: never checking tenants' insurance certificates, not telling the agent when a space goes empty or a restaurant moves in, hiring a contractor with no workers' comp certificate, assuming liability covers tenants' spaces, and assuming tenants' policies cover the building. Each is easy to fix before a loss.
Photo by NordWood Themes
on Unsplash
- Two are about paper you never collect: tenants' certificates and a contractor's workers' comp certificate.
- Two are about what your policy was told or written for: a change you never reported, and a liability policy built for less than you assumed.
- The fifth is about the lease: who insures a tenant's build-out and who covers your lost rent.
Which insurance mistakes do commercial building owners make most?
Five, each easy to make when the building is full and nothing has gone wrong. The table shows what each can cost and how to fix it.
| Mistake | What it can cost | The fix |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Never checking tenants' certificates | A claim with no proof the tenant is insured | Collect each certificate and put the expiry on your calendar |
| 2. Not telling your agent about a change | A policy that describes a different building | Tell your agent before a new kind of tenant moves in |
| 3. Hiring a contractor with no comp certificate | Your policy asked to pay a hurt worker | Collect a current certificate before work starts |
| 4. Assuming liability covers tenants' spaces | A claim from inside a space your policy limits or excludes | Ask what the policy limits and excludes |
| 5. Assuming tenants' policies cover your building | Build-out and lost rent that nobody pays for | Settle both in the lease and ask your agent |
To see what a building policy can leave out, read five coverage gaps in a typical commercial building policy. To see what to carry, read what insurance a commercial building owner needs.
Mistake 1: Do I know my tenants are still insured?
Not unless you check every year. Your lease may ask each tenant to carry insurance, but nobody renews a certificate for you.
Picture an owner who collected a certificate from each new tenant and filed it. Three years later, one tenant's policy has lapsed and nobody noticed. A customer falls in that tenant's shop, and the claim names the owner as well. The lease required the insurance, but the owner cannot show it is in force, and her own policy may be asked to respond.
A certificate of insuranceCertificate of Insurance (COI) A one-page proof of your coverage, showing the insurer, policy number, and limits, that you hand to a landlord or client. Insurers call it a certificate of insurance. more → is a one-page proof of the tenant's coverage. It is information only and gives you no rights under the tenant's policy, and a promise on it to warn you of cancellation is generally no longer available. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) So collect the endorsement that names you, put each expiry date on your calendar, and ask for a new certificate every renewal. Our guide to what a certificate of insurance shows explains how to read one, and to see what to ask tenants to carry, read what to require from tenants.
What to say to your agent. “Which tenants' certificates do I have on file, which have expired, and do I hold the endorsement that names me on each one?”
Mistake 2: Does my insurer know what is in my building today?
Only if you have told your agent. Your policy is priced from a description of the building and how it is used, and a new kind of tenant changes that description.
Picture an owner who rents a ground-floor shop to a restaurant in the fall. She renews with the same answers as the year before. A kitchen fire starts. Her insurer can question the claim, because its file describes a building with no restaurant in it.
An insurer reviews four things to price a building: how it is built, what it is used for, how it is protected and what stands next to it. (Source: International Risk Management Institute) A restaurant changes the second one. So tell your agent before a restaurant signs, and whenever a space goes empty. Do not wait for renewal.
What to say to your agent. “Here is what changed in the building since you wrote the policy. Does the policy describe all of it, and does anything change in the price or the terms?”
Mistake 3: What if a contractor I hire has no workers' comp?
Some state laws, such as Kansas's and Massachusetts's, say who pays when a contractor has no workers' comp. A certificate collected before the work starts answers the question early.
Picture an owner who hires a roofer by handshake to patch the roof, and the roofer has no workers' comp. A worker falls and is badly hurt. The claim looks for someone to pay, and her own insurer may be asked to pay what the roofer's should have.
The laws differ by state. Kansas ties it to work that is part of the hiring party's trade or business, and treats a current certificate as proof of cover. (Source: Kansas Revisor of Statutes, K.S.A. 44-503) Massachusetts says that when a contractor doing an insured person's work is uninsured, the hiring person's insurer pays the compensation and may recover it from the contractor. (Source: Massachusetts General Laws, c. 152, section 18) Whether a rule like this reaches a building owner can turn on the work and the contract, so ask your attorney. Our guide to workers' comp laws by state links each state's page. Everywhere, ask the roofer or the cleaning company for a current certificate before the first day.
What to say to your agent. “If a contractor on my building has no workers' comp and a worker is hurt, what does my policy do, and what should I collect before work starts?”
Mistake 4: Does my liability coverage reach what happens inside my tenants' spaces?
Not always. A liability policy for a building owner can be written for the building and common areas only, and some exclude certain claims even there.
Picture an owner who rents a ground-floor unit to a bar. A fight breaks out one night and a customer who is hurt sues the bar and the owner. She assumed her general liability coverage followed the building into every unit. If her policy limits cover to space she rents out, or excludes a fight, her insurer can decline the claim.
Lessor's risk onlyLessor's Risk Only A liability classification for an owner who rents space to others and does not run the operations in it. Coverage is written for the building and common areas, not for what the tenants do inside. more → is a liability classification for an owner who rents space to others and does not run the operations in it. Assault and battery coverageAssault and Battery Coverage Coverage for claims that someone was physically attacked or hurt in a fight at your business, which many liability policies exclude. Insurers call it assault and battery coverage. more → pays claims that someone was attacked or hurt in a fight. Ask whether your policy limits cover to the space you rent out, whether it excludes assault, and whether each tenant carries its own liability policy naming you.
What to say to your agent. “Does my liability policy limit cover to the space I rent out, does it exclude assault, and where is that written?”
Mistake 5: Do my tenants' policies cover my building and my lost rent?
Usually they are built for the tenant's own losses. Who insures a tenant's build-out, and who covers the owner's rent, is decided by the lease.
Picture an owner whose tenant built out a clinic suite with new walls, flooring and fixtures. A fire damages the suite. The tenant's policy covers its own equipment and supplies, the owner's policy covers the building, and the lease says nothing about the build-out. Each side assumes the other insures it, and she can be left to pay for the rebuild herself.
Leasehold improvementsLeasehold Improvements Walls, flooring, fixtures and other build-out inside a rented space. The lease decides whether the owner or the tenant insures them. Insurers call them leasehold improvements. more → are the walls, flooring and fixtures built inside a rented space. In a multi-tenant building it often makes sense for the party who insures the shell to insure them too, and the allocation is often overlooked, which can leave gaps or overlaps. (Source: Eidson, commercial-lease insurance paper, 2017) Rent often stops while a space cannot be used, and your mortgage and taxes keep coming. Your own loss-of-rents cover is built for that, not the tenant's policy. Ask your attorney how your lease reads, and put the answer in writing.
What to say to your agent. “Does my property limit include tenants' build-out, and does my policy replace my rent while a tenant's space cannot be used?”
Common questions about commercial building insurance mistakes
Some do. Mistakes 2 and 3 apply to any commercial building. Mistakes 1, 4 and 5 apply to the part you rent out to others.
Collecting certificates and writing terms into the lease does not change your policy. Adding coverage, or telling your insurer about a change in how the building is used, can change the price. Ask for each change priced separately.
At every expiry date shown on a certificate, and whenever a tenant renews its lease or changes how it uses the space.
Check your commercial building policy for these five
Bring your current policy and we will go through it with you.